Pizza is the great kosher equalizer. It’s the dinner every kid will eat, the easy Sunday lunch, and for a lot of families, the Saturday night tradition the minute Shabbos is over. Miami has more good kosher pizza than most people realize, from classic New York slice shops to brick-oven Italian and artisan pies.
Here are the kosher pizza spots worth knowing in Miami Beach, Surfside, Sunny Isles, Aventura and North Miami Beach: what each one does best, what it costs, and who’s open Saturday night.
Kosher pizza in Miami at a glance
| Pizzeria | Area | Style | Hashgacha | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Fialkoff’s | Miami Beach | Classic NY slice shop | Kosher Miami | A quick slice on Arthur Godfrey |
| Fialkoff’s Surfside | Surfside | Classic NY slice shop | Kosher Miami | Pizza after the beach |
| Rustiko | Surfside | Sit-down Italian bistro | Kosher Miami | Date night or a family dinner out |
| Cine Citta | Surfside | Brick-oven Italian | Kosher Miami | Outdoor seating with kids |
| Slice Kosher Pizzeria | Sunny Isles | New York–style, new in 2026 | ORB | Beach-hotel crowd, thick NY pies |
| Milano’s | Aventura | Pizza, pasta, Italian | Kosher Miami | Late nights and Saturday night |
| Mama Pizza | Aventura | Family pizzeria + coffee shop | Kosher Miami | Early birds (opens 10 AM) |
| Foozo | North Miami Beach | Artisan pizza & focaccia | Kosher Miami | Yoshon pizza, Pas Yisroel |
| Jerusalem Pizza | North Miami Beach | Old-school slice shop + falafel | Kosher Miami | Pizza and falafel in one order |
All are dairy and Cholov Yisroel per their agency listings. Prices and hours come from each pizzeria’s own site or ordering page as of October 2026. Online-ordering prices can run higher than in-store, so call to confirm.
Miami Beach & Surfside
Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza (Miami Beach)
544 Arthur Godfrey Rd · 305-397-8395 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
- The story: Fialkoff’s has been making kosher pizza since 1973, starting in the Catskills, and this is its Arthur Godfrey Road shop, right in the middle of Miami Beach’s kosher strip.
- What to order: A slice of the signature pie (about $4.85 online) or a whole signature pizza (about $27). The “sweet pizza” is a best-seller. Mac and cheese, penne vodka and baked ziti run about $18; garlic knots about $7.
- Good to know: Opens at 11 AM, with online ordering and delivery.
Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza (Surfside)
9463 Harding Ave · 305-397-8324 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
The same menu on Harding Avenue, a block from the beach. A plain pie runs about $21 online, which makes it one of the cheapest family dinners in Surfside. Our Surfside kids guide has the full family game plan for the strip.
Rustiko
9476 Harding Ave · 305-560-5650 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
When you want pizza but also an actual night out. Rustiko is a sit-down dairy Italian bistro with pizza, pasta and a real dessert menu, and it takes reservations online. Good for a date night or a family dinner where the adults want more than a slice.
Cine Citta Caffe
9544 Harding Ave · 305-866-8688 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel · Pas Yisroel
Brick-oven pizza and handmade bread on the north end of Harding, with outdoor seating, which is a lifesaver with restless kids. A Surfside staple for more than a decade.
Sunny Isles & Aventura
Slice Kosher Pizzeria
18090 Collins Ave, Sunny Isles Beach · Dairy · ORB · Cholov Yisroel
The newcomer. Slice opened in early 2026 on Collins Avenue and does New York–style pies with a thicker crust, plus salads, appetizers and desserts. It’s built for the Sunny Isles condo and hotel crowd, so it’s an easy walk from many of the beach towers.
Milano’s Kosher
19090 NE 29th Ave, Aventura · 786-640-6400 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
- Why go: Pizza, pasta and salads near Aventura Mall, with dine-in, pickup and delivery.
- Hours that matter: Open until 11 PM Sunday to Wednesday and until midnight on Thursday. On Saturday night it reopens one hour after Shabbos and stays open until 12:30 AM, the latest Saturday-night pizza on this list.
Mama Pizza
19200 W Dixie Hwy, Aventura · 305-974-5549 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
- Why go: A family-owned pizzeria and coffee shop that has been feeding Miami-Dade and Broward for more than 20 years: pizza, calzones, pasta, ravioli, salads and pastries.
- Hours: Opens at 10 AM Sunday to Thursday (until 9 PM), Friday 10 AM to 2 PM, and Saturday night 8 PM to midnight. It’s the earliest-opening spot here, so it works for a late breakfast or coffee too.
North Miami Beach
Foozo Artisan Pizza
2520 NE Miami Gardens Dr · 305-682-9692 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel · Pas Yisroel
- Why go: Artisan pizza, focaccia and sandwiches, a step up from the classic slice shop.
- The detail that matters: Kosher Miami lists Foozo’s pizza as Yoshon, which is rare. If your family keeps Yoshon, this is the pizza place to know.
- Hours: Sunday to Thursday 11:30 AM to 10 PM, Friday until 3 PM.
Jerusalem Pizza
761 NE 167th St · 305-653-6662 · Dairy · Kosher Miami · Cholov Yisroel
- Why go: An old-school slice shop that also does falafel, so one order covers the pizza kids and the falafel adults.
- What it costs: Whole pies about $24–$26 online, with specialty pies like white, Greek, veggie and baked-ziti pizza. Mac and cheese, baked ziti and spinach lasagna run about $18–$20, and falafel plates and pitas are on the menu too.
- Good to know: Opens at 11 AM; order on Slice or by phone.
Saturday night pizza: who reopens after Shabbos?
- Milano’s (Aventura): one hour after Shabbos until 12:30 AM.
- Mama Pizza (Aventura): 8 PM to midnight.
- Everyone else: hours shift with sunset through the year, so call or check Instagram before you pile the kids in the car. In winter, when Shabbos ends early, more places reopen; in summer, many stay closed.
Quick tips
- Cholov Yisroel: every pizzeria on this list is listed as Cholov Yisroel by its agency. Always check the certificate on the wall.
- Yoshon: Foozo is the one to know. Kosher Miami lists its pizza as Yoshon.
- Pizza for a crowd: two plain pies and garlic knots feed a family of five for roughly $50–$60 at most of these spots. Order ahead on Friday or Saturday night, since everyone has the same idea.
- Meat and dairy: all of these are dairy. Planning dinner and then ice cream? Pizza night makes it easy.
FAQ: Kosher pizza in Miami
Where can I get kosher pizza in Miami Beach?
Fialkoff’s Kosher Pizza on Arthur Godfrey Road (Kosher Miami) is the classic Miami Beach slice shop. In Surfside, a few minutes north, there’s a second Fialkoff’s plus sit-down pizza at Rustiko and Cine Citta.
Which kosher pizza places are open Saturday night?
Milano’s in Aventura reopens one hour after Shabbos and stays open until 12:30 AM, and Mama Pizza in Aventura is open 8 PM to midnight. Other pizzerias vary by season, so call ahead.
Is there Yoshon kosher pizza in Miami?
Yes. Kosher Miami lists the pizza at Foozo in North Miami Beach as Yoshon. It’s also Cholov Yisroel and Pas Yisroel.
Is there kosher pizza in Sunny Isles?
Yes. Slice Kosher Pizzeria at 18090 Collins Ave opened in 2026 under ORB supervision, serving New York–style pies.
What is the cheapest kosher pizza in Miami?
A plain pie at Fialkoff’s lists at about $21 online, and Jerusalem Pizza’s cheese pie at about $24. In-store prices are often a little lower than delivery-app prices.
More family dining: our kid-friendly Surfside guide, plus every kosher spot by city: Miami Beach, Surfside and Aventura.
Know a kosher pizza spot we missed? Let us know and we’ll add it.